Under the current state planning laws, 900 new houses may soon
engulf Catherine Hill Bay. This idyllic Central Coast coalmining
town from the 1870s comprises 100 historic homes and intact
heritage streetscapes nestled in rolling green hinterland on a
pristine surf beach. The area is rich in social history and abounds
in biodiversity and endangered species.
Rose Property Group plans to build 600 houses there, and Coal
Allied 300 dwellings. Both proponents have signed memorandums
of understanding with the Minister for Planning to facilitate the
developments. If these plans proceed, “Catho’s” heritage,
environmental and aesthetic values will be obliterated.
A ministerial decision on the Rose Group application is expected
imminently. Public submissions on the Coal Allied plans close
this Friday.
Catherine Hill Bay’s significance has been recognised by a
rollcall of authorities. It is zoned as a conservation area and has
been nominated for state heritage listing. In 2006 the Land and
Environment Court rejected Rosecorp’s earlier proposal for 600
homes. That year the NSW Department of Planning recommended against
development on environmental and heritage grounds.
The developments are now being considered under Part 3A of the
NSW Environmental Planning and Assessment Act, which gives the
Planning Minister the authority to override environmental and
planning legislation and policies on projects deemed “state
significant”. The National Trust is deeply concerned about the
growing use of these powers. The application of Part 3A to green
light Catherine Hill Bay will set a dangerous precedent for the
coast, and other places of environmental and heritage significance,
raising developer expectations.
The role of the trust, the nation’s largest community-based
conservation charity, is to safeguard natural and cultural heritage
and to encourage Australians to appreciate that each generation has
a responsibility to the next.
Yet we are not anti-development, and are acutely conscious of
the need to provide housing and infrastructure to support our
population and economy.
However, the construction of 900 dwellings at Catherine Hill
Bay, with the inevitable impacts for infrastructure and the natural
and built environment, would represent the triumph of development
over the environmental and social values that the broader community
holds dear. What will our children’s children think of us when they
reflect on an irreplaceable heritage and environmental jewel,
trampled by the relentless march of capital over community and
culture?
Tina Jackson Executive Director National Trust (NSW)
Sydney
Apart from superwoman, 2020 vision looks blokey
I am a senior female human resources executive, specialising in
remuneration and organisational effectiveness. I have lived all
over the world and returned quite recently from nine years working
in New York, Istanbul and Europe. Australia has a reputation for
its blokey, misogynist work environment. My work has given me great
insight into how inequality (particularly in relation to pay)
becomes entrenched in organisations and cultures.
To have the Prime Minister include just one female in a
10-person leadership team that will discuss Australia’s future is
disgraceful (”Rudd’s summit slammed as a one-woman show”, February
27). It sends a message to thousands of women that it’s not worth
bothering. That the one female is a beautiful celebrity - an
actress - rubs salt into the wound.
Amanda Wilson Balmain
The businesswoman Catherine Harris apparently thinks that the
Prime Minister should understand “that most women are not actually
at home looking after the grandchildren or children %26#133; they’ve
got lots of other jobs as well”.
Mrs Harris appears to assume that a woman who looks after her
children or her grandchildren at home is incapable of contributing
to a significant national debate.
This attitude shows scant regard for the diversity of
circumstances in which many women find themselves.
Of course, there should be more women on this committee, but
they need not necessarily be drawn only from high-profile positions
in the business world.
That would be decidedly unbalanced.
Elizabeth Chandler Mount Victoria
After the very positive reception to Kevin Rudd’s announcement
that Cate Blanchett is one of 10 committee members guiding
Australia’s 2020 Summit, the following are other positions this
very versatile actress is being considered for by the Federal
Government: governor of the Reserve Bank; leader of the Australian
mission to the next round of Kyoto Protocol talks; Australian
ambassador for peace, Darfur region, North Africa; head of
emergency services, Royal North Shore Hospital; special rapporteur
for Aboriginal intervention, Northern Territory; astronaut on
NASA’s 2015 manned mission to Mars; and governor-general of
Australia.
Please note there is absolutely no truth to the rumour that she
will be the next premier of NSW. Some things just can’t be
fixed.
Ben Cardillo Epping
There may be only one woman on the 2020 committee - but boy,
what a woman.
Mike Doyle Darlington
The summit will be just like the great republic debate, where a
selection of high-profile (mostly) men participated. That debate
turned out to be a dog. Will the 2020 summit also be just a
propaganda exercise?
How many real people, such as the women at the grassroots of
local communities, will end up there?
Mary Jenkins Spearwood (WA)
Never have I heard so much whingeing and whining about so
little.
Each of the 10 chairwomen and men at the 2020 Summit can invite
99 women, and six of the groups will be co-chaired by women.
Marilyn Shepherd Kensington
Hollow promises for the north-west
For years the Baulkham Hills Shire Council has been told to
increase densities in Sydney’s north-west to accommodate the
population growth on the promise that real infrastructure in the
form of heavy rail will be provided.
The targets for that growth through development were set and are
being implemented by council and enforced by the State
Government.
We’ve grown and the densities are clearly evident, but all we
are left with is the traffic chaos, empty promises and more
speculation about the removal of the rail line.
Unless there is absolute proof that the State Government is
going to provide the north-west rail line, the upgrade of
Showground Road and more buses, no increase in densities above the
absolute minimum should be approved by the local council
involved.
The people of the north-west have had enough of overdevelopment
based on empty promises.
Cr Peter Dimbrowsky Baulkham Hills
Metro rail systems work fine in highly built-up areas like
London and Paris (”Bye heavy rail, now for a north-west metro”,
February 26), but Sydney’s north-west is much more spread out.
If the NSW Transport Minister, John Watkins, needs proof of how
passengers shun the all-stops services for longer trips, he need
look no further than his electorate, where his own constituents
prefer to crowd out the Central Coast express services to travel to
Eastwood and Epping, rather than use the all-stops services.
People simply won’t use a first-stop-Rozelle service to get to
Rouse Hill.
Bruce Stafford Tascott
Clearly for certain key members of the NSW Labor family the
Light on the Hill only has a future if privately powered.
So maybe it’s time Frankie “The Dinner” Sartor, Mickie “Power of
One” Costa and “Macho” Morris Iemma (have you seen the size of his
water cannon? It’s huge!) left the True Believers and formed their
own gang: the ADP (Australian Developers Party).
Nick Franklin Katoomba
Yesterday in Parliament our embattled Premier stated that
Malcolm Turnbull (27 per cent) had an approval rating three times
greater than Barry O’Farrell (13 per cent).
He is clearly using the highly specialised Macquarie Street
mathematics system used by all past and present health ministers,
which does away with the usual customs employed in rounding numbers
up and down.
Perhaps arithmetic could be introduced as an optional elective
at the table of knowledge? Numbers don’t develop new relationships
with each other - their relationships are fixed. If I have two
kebabs, even if one is a tiny bit larger than the other, it would
be absurd to say I had three kebabs.
Jonathan Egan West Ryde
The concept of democracy is a myth. The definition of democracy
is “government of the people by the people”. But our only input
into government is once every few years when we vote for one of two
political parties. After that the winner does what it chooses
unhindered.
The best example of this is the current electricity
privatisation proposal, where three-quarters of the population of
NSW oppose the sale yet the Iemma Government is going ahead with
it. Is this democracy?
John Poleson Kingsford
Mind their own business
What a breathtaking piece of gratuitous advice from the Business
Council of Australia (”Freeze new spending, business tells PM”,
February 25). Its deputy chief executive, Melinda Cilento, needs to
tell the likes of Macquarie Group and many other Australian
corporations that executive salaries present a far more significant
issue requiring the attention of Australia’s businesses than
government spending.
Just imagine the added employment or the enhanced infrastructure
investment to be gained by applying just half a Macquarie Group
CEO’s salary to the economy in one year.
Russell Mills Redfern
Driven bats
Sydney’s Royal Botanic Gardens is just that: a botanic garden for
the protection, display, scientific study, education about and
propagation of plants, not a stinking bat colony (”Batanic gardens
to evict squatters”, Letters, February 27). The bats are destroying
very old and irreplaceable trees.
We have taken overseas visitors to the restaurant in the gardens
and had to speak loudly to make ourselves heard above the din of
the bats. Walking through the gardens, I have been shat upon from a
great height. It was pretty awful for me but dreadful when it
happened to my infant granddaughter, as bats are known to carry
disease.
We are coming up to the bicentenary of the gardens. The bats
must go.
Kate Chivers Epping
Tim Entwisle has been shirking his responsibility for the past
10 years by failing to act on the only advice that will move the
bat colony: plant some fast-growing, hardy natives in an
appropriate place in the gardens and then net the palm grove.
Instead he has been pursuing a policy that is guaranteed to
increase the amount of damage to the trees, that of noise
disturbance, which cause the bats to repeatedly take off and
land.
In the past 20-odd years, one successful colony relocation has
been undertaken, while dozens have not worked. Mr Entwisle is
wasting still more time to protect the palm grove by going down a
path which is all but guaranteed to fail.
Storm Stanford Lewisham
Responsibility ducked
It is impossible to quantify the role of public money and the
subsequent business goodwill that has underpinned the recent
adventures of ABC Learning. It is also very difficult to assess the
social impact of cherry-picking sites, the concomitant closure of
community-based child-care centres and alliances with other private
schooling initiatives.
Now a light is being shone on the folly of carelessly diverting
public responsibilities to the for-profit sector. Affordable child
care is always at the top of reasons for gaps in workforce
participation and lack of opportunities for women.
Governments should apply their resources to publicly managed,
staffed and properly supervised agencies and leave the private
sector to be just that.
Gus Plater Saratoga
Hey Dumbo, we’ve already got Morris in Blunderland
Mickey Mouse in White Bay? Wouldn’t work %26#133; too close to the
real thing in Macquarie Street (”Disney eyes White Bay”, February
27).
David Calvey Vaucluse
Who would contemplate besmirching our beautiful harbour with
this cultural Chernobyl? I had the unfortunate experience of
visiting EuroDisney last year. While I put on a brave face for my
children, I was paying $200 per person for the right to queue all
day and loiter around tacky souvenir shops.
We already have our own iconic home-grown harbour theme park -
Luna Park.
John Arneil Fairlight
A whole new ball game
Roy Masters may be right when he says the AFL will fail in western
Sydney (”AFL imperialism doomed to fail”, February 27) but he’s got
a nerve to call it “imperialism”.
It was the rugby codes that colonised NSW when the schools gave
them preference just after federation. Australian football was
quite well established here by then. So why is it the rugby league
claque pretends Australian football was never played in Sydney
until Warwick Capper arrived in 1982? Is Masters afraid the
indigenous game might really catch on if it is played in
schools?
Tony Barrell Balmain
Prelude to peace
Perhaps it is because the New York Philharmonic was part of a US
diplomatic plan that they were welcome in North Korea.
Whatever the background, once again the ability of music to rise
above economic or cultural imperialism and draw people together has
been demonstrated.
Let’s hope an invitation is extended to an Australian ensemble
soon.
Philip Cooney Wentworth Falls
It makes fashion sense
Allan Tieu (”Society grooms men who blush”, February 27) challenges
the norm that only females should wear make-up. He’s quite right to
question the fashion rules. I want to know why you have to be at
least 185 centimetres tall and no more than a few centimetres wide
to be a model. Do clothes really hang better on stick insects?
C’mon designers - be brave and use a variety of model sizes, so
that the rest of us can relate to your creativity.
Wendy Crew Lane Cove
Allan Tieu is correct in asserting that the wearing of make-up
by men no longer signifies “sexual orientation or subculture” - but
it does signify the resurgence of a loathsome beast that has
remained in obscurity since the Regency. Ladies and gentlemen, I
give you the fop.
Scott Hillard New Lambton
Lunch can spice up your life
David Breeze (Letters, February 27), I agree that making your own
lunch is the sensible option. So is wearing Clarks shoes, a spencer
in winter and chewing your food 20 times before swallowing. These
things are also incredibly dull. Feel free to wallow in a life of
mundanity, but please be kind enough to allow us risky people to
live on the edge and splash out on an $8 meal at lunchtime. Some of
us can even afford it without risking bankruptcy. Crazy, I
know.
Rebecca Gordon Surry Hills
Tags:
actress,
attitude,
australians,
cate,
cate blanchett,
dwelling,
europe,
Food,
ford,
job,
malcolm turnbull,
real people,
target,
ups
Related posts